Additive Manufacturing for Toolmakers: Processes, Materials and Where Each Fits

Additive Manufacturing for Toolmakers: Processes, Materials and Where Each Fits

Additive manufacturing builds a part by adding material layer by layer instead of cutting it from a block. For a tool shop it is not a replacement for milling, EDM and grinding. It is a fourth capability that does three things the other machines cannot: it makes internal geometry such as curved cooling channels, it makes a usable shape with no tooling and almost no programming, and it adds material to an existing tool. This article describes the processes that matter for molds and dies, what each one delivers, and which jobs it suits.

What additive changes for a toolmaker

Every tooling application of additive manufacturing falls into one of four groups. Knowing which group a job belongs to decides the process.

GroupWhat is printedTypical exampleMain process
Better toolingA steel insert with features that cannot be machinedCore insert with conformal coolingLaser powder bed fusion
Faster toolingA short-life tool made in daysPolymer mold insert for 50 molded partsStereolithography, material jetting
No toolingThe part itself200 nylon housings, 10 metal bracketsPowder bed (polymer or metal)
Repaired toolingNew material on an old toolRebuilt edge on a die casting insertDirected energy deposition

In all four groups the printed surface is a near-net shape. Fits, shut-offs, sealing faces and polished cavity surfaces are still machined. The printer joins the machine shop; it does not bypass it.

The metal processes

Three metal processes are relevant to tooling. They differ in how the metal is delivered and how it is fused.

Working principle of the three metal processes used in tooling
Working principle of the three metal processes used in tooling

Laser powder bed fusion (LPBF)

A recoater spreads a powder layer 30–60 µm thick and a laser melts the cross-section of the part. The platform drops by one layer and the cycle repeats. Density is above 99.5 % and the mechanical properties after heat treatment match wrought steel closely. Any internal shape is possible as long as the loose powder can be removed afterwards. This is the process for conformal-cooled inserts, vented inserts and small complex cores.

The limits are size, speed and surface. Common machines build about 250 × 250 × 300 mm. Build rates for steel are in the range of 5–20 cm³ per hour for each laser, so a fist-sized insert takes one to two days. The as-built surface is rough and every functional face needs stock for machining.

Directed energy deposition (DED)

A nozzle feeds powder or wire into a melt pool created by a laser or an electric arc. The head moves on a CNC machine or a robot and deposits beads 0.5–5 mm wide. DED works on existing parts and on curved surfaces, so it is the process for repair, hardfacing and adding features to a finished insert. Laser cladding is the same process used for surface layers. Accuracy is low and the deposit is always machined afterwards.

Binder jetting

A print head deposits liquid binder on a powder bed. The result is a fragile "green" part that is sintered in a furnace, where it shrinks by 15–20 % in each direction. There is no melting during printing, so there is little residual stress and no support structure. The process is fast and suits small parts in quantity. The sintering shrinkage limits accuracy on larger parts. In tooling its most useful form is sand binder jetting, which prints sand molds and cores for casting without a pattern.

PropertyLPBFDED (laser, powder)Binder jetting (metal)
Feature accuracy as built±0.05 to ±0.1 mm±0.3 to ±1 mm±0.1 to ±0.3 mm on small parts
Surface roughness Ra as built5–15 µm10–40 µm3–12 µm
Density> 99.5 %> 99.5 %96–99 %
Tooling materialsMaraging 1.2709, H13, stainless mold steels, copper alloysTool steels, cobalt and nickel alloys, carbide-filled alloys17-4PH, 316L, some tool steels
Internal channelsYesLimitedYes, in small parts
Works on an existing partOnly on a flat preformYesNo
Main tooling useConformal-cooled insertsRepair, cladding, design changesSmall inserts, sand molds and cores

The polymer processes

Polymer printers cost far less than metal ones and most tool shops start here. Four processes cover almost every need.

ProcessHow it worksAccuracySurfaceUse in the tool shop
Stereolithography (SLA, DLP)Light cures liquid resin layer by layer±0.1 mmSmooth, Ra 1–3 µmShort-run mold inserts, masters for silicone molds, casting patterns
Material jettingPrint heads jet resin droplets cured by UV light±0.1 mmSmoothShort-run mold inserts, appearance models
Powder bed (SLS, MJF)Laser or infrared energy fuses nylon powder±0.3 mmGrainy, Ra 6–12 µmEnd-use parts in small batches, grippers, fixtures
Filament extrusion (FFF)A nozzle lays down molten filament±0.2 to ±0.5 mmVisible layersJigs, fixtures, check gauges, forming dies for thin sheet

Two properties decide whether a polymer print can act as a tool: stiffness at temperature and surface quality. Filled high-temperature resins from SLA keep their shape against molten plastic for tens to hundreds of shots. Nylon powder bed parts are tough but too rough and too porous for a cavity surface. Filament parts are strong in the layer plane and weak across it, so they are loaded in compression, as in a forming die or a fixture.

Typical as-built tolerance and surface roughness. Every additive process is rougher and less accurate than finish milling
Typical as-built tolerance and surface roughness. Every additive process is rougher and less accurate than finish milling

Where each process fits

JobProcessWhyWatch for
Core or cavity insert with a hot spot that drilled lines cannot reachLPBF in maraging steelChannels follow the cavity surfacePowder removal, water quality, machining stock
Worn or chipped edge, cracked insert, late design changeDED or laser claddingLow heat input, CNC-controlled depositRemove nitrided layer and cracks first
20–100 molded parts in the real plasticSLA or material jetting insert in a steel frameInsert ready in one or two daysLow pressure, long cycle, large draft
50–500 plastic parts, no tooling budgetPowder bed nylon, printed directlyNo tool, no draft, design can change between batchesMaterial is nylon, not the production resin
Fixtures, soft jaws, check gauges, robot grippersFFF or powder bedCheap, light, made overnightAdd steel bushings at wear points
Forming die for 10–300 sheet metal partsFFF with fibre-filled nylon or polycarbonateLoaded in compression, easy springback iterationsNo cutting edges in polymer
5–50 castings before a die existsSand binder jettingSand mold with no patternProperties differ from die cast parts
Gas vents in a closed area of the cavityLPBF insert with a porous zoneAir escapes through the steel itselfPores clog; plan cleaning

Additive is the wrong choice where conventional machining is already fast. A flat insert with straight drilled lines, a simple electrode or a block-shaped core is cheaper and more accurate from bar stock. The rule is to print the geometry that cannot be cut and to cut everything else.

What printing does not give you

  • Finished surfaces. Plan 0.3–0.5 mm of stock on every fit, shut-off and cavity face, and more on large parts.
  • Optical polish without risk. Residual pores of 10–50 µm can open during polishing. Printed steel reaches a good technical polish but is a risk for mirror surfaces.
  • Size. Most LPBF machines stop near 300 mm. Larger tools are built as hybrid inserts or left to conventional methods.
  • Low material cost. Powder costs several times more than bar stock and machine time is charged by the hour. A printed insert is paid back by cycle time, scrap or lead time, not by its own price.
  • Freedom from design rules. Overhangs below about 45° need supports, loose powder must have a way out, and residual stress distorts thin sections.

Buy a machine or buy the service

The two families call for different decisions.

  1. Polymer first, in-house. A resin or filament printer pays back on fixtures, gauges and trial inserts within months and builds design experience at low risk.
  2. Metal through a service bureau. A metal LPBF installation needs the machine, powder handling, inert gas, a furnace and trained staff. Until there is steady work for it, buy the builds and keep design and finishing in-house.
  3. Keep the value in the tool shop. The bureau prints. The toolmaker designs the channels, defines the stock, heat treats, machines, polishes and guarantees the tool. That is where the know-how and the margin are.
  4. Review when volume is stable. When builds are ordered every week and lead time from the bureau limits delivery, the case for an in-house machine can be calculated from real numbers.

A build request to a bureau should state the material and required hardness, the heat treatment, the build orientation if it matters, the faces that carry machining stock, the channel openings that must be free of powder, and the acceptance test, usually a flow and pressure test of each circuit.

Common mistakes

MistakeResultCorrect approach
Printing a shape that could be milledHigher cost, lower accuracyPrint only what machining cannot produce
No machining stock on functional facesInsert cannot be fittedAdd 0.3–0.5 mm and define datums before the build
Closed or dead-end channelsTrapped powder, blocked coolingEvery channel has an inlet, an outlet and a clear path
Judging a printed polymer insert by steel mold standardsDisappointment with life and toleranceUse it for tens of parts, not thousands
Validating production properties on printed partsWrong conclusions about strength and shrinkageTest function and fit; confirm properties on tooled parts
Buying a metal printer before the workload existsIdle capitalStart with a bureau and build demand

Key takeaways

  • Additive manufacturing gives a tool shop internal geometry, tool-free shapes and local material addition. It does not remove the need for machining.
  • LPBF makes dense steel inserts with conformal cooling, DED repairs and modifies existing tools, and binder jetting serves small parts and sand molds.
  • Polymer printers are the low-cost entry: resin for short-run mold inserts, nylon for direct parts, filament for fixtures and forming dies.
  • Print what cannot be cut, leave stock on everything that must fit, and start metal work through a bureau while keeping design and finishing in-house.

Related Articles

3D Printed Mold Inserts for Short-Run Injection Molding

How to design and run 3D printed polymer mold inserts for 10 to 100 molded parts: materials, draft, gates, process settings, insert life and failure modes.

Small Batches: Print the Part, Print the Tool, or Cut the Tool?

Break-even calculation for small batches: 3D printed parts, printed mold inserts, aluminum molds and steel molds, with routes for metal and sheet metal parts.

Repairing Molds and Dies with Laser Cladding and Directed Energy Deposition

Mold and die repair by TIG, laser welding and laser cladding compared: heat-affected zone, dilution, filler choice, repair procedure and when to replace.

Printing Tool Steel: Maraging, H13 and What Happens After the Build

Printable tool steels compared, with the full post-processing route: stress relief, age hardening, machining allowance, polishing limits and surface treatment.

Conformal Cooling in Injection Molds and Die Casting Inserts: Design Rules and Payback

Design rules for conformal cooling channels in printed mold inserts: diameter, pitch, distance to cavity, flow, hybrid inserts, HPDC limits and payback.

Share Article